IEEE Policy Regarding Prescreening of Articles by Editors
Editors may prescreen articles immediately after they are submitted and before they are transmitted to referees for evaluation. The purpose of such prescreening is to verify that the article adheres to minimum criteria set forth by IEEE, as well as by the organizational unit responsible for the specific publication. Typical prescreening measures include the following:
- a. The author(s) have followed the IEEE guidelines for style.
- b. The author(s) have not obviously violated IEEE Policies.
- c. The article is comprehensible (in other words, not so poorly written that it is unreadable).
- d. The subject and contents of the article meet the scope of the periodical or a specific issue.
- e. The article meets a minimum criterion for technical substance established for the periodical.
If the Editor assesses that a submission has met prescreening criteria 3.a through 3.d but has not met criterion 3.e, the Editor shall consult with at least two members of the editorial board for concurrence. Rejection on the basis of criterion 3.e shall require the general agreement of the Editor and those consulted. An article is considered in review if it passes the prescreening process and is forwarded to referees. An “administrative reject” refers to an article that does not meet the prescreening measures and is, therefore, returned to the author(s) with explanation.